So, Ryan and I went to the Blue Grill tonight and I was telling him about our time there; how you were so sad and I had to play talkative… how we were talking about “our stories.” How I wanted to hear about the non-jerk side of the Ben story, and how after all was said and drank, he didn’t sound like the jerk that left you hanging; he sounded like the kind of man you would move in with.
The first thing he said was, “So, you told her about the coin toss.” And, I said, “No. I forgot about that, you asshole.” Thus, the story of the flip.
It was fall of 2001 and Ryan and I had been dating for about a year. Despite his adamant behavior in the beginning (telling me he thought he loved me after our first kiss, leaving presents on my doorstep, calling me every day), after a year of flushed cheeks, less than a moment apart, he took me to the park in a moment of despair. He had choices before him–settling down or the partying lifestyle to which he was accustomed. We sat there, in the chilly fall air with the heater running. There were a few late lillies blooming on the bush closest to the car, and in a moment of escapism, I left the car to pick one, dying from frostbite. It resided in a notebook of mine for years (the move to New York cleared many things out).
That night, after hours of talking, reminding him of how he said he loved me, he was faced with a decision: choose me, or not. Choose to settle, or choose to go to shows. Choose to love himself, or a family. Do you know what he did? He took a nickel out of his pocket and said, “If it’s heads, we’ll stay together.” Two flips later, two tails later, and many moments of delayed response, he said, “Maybe we should stay together.”
Either a forgiving lover or a sad sap, I forgave him. I loved him. I married him, despite the flip.